Peters & Peters

ESG Enforcement Tracker

Charting the rise of criminal and regulatory enforcement

French Senate investigates Nestlé and Perrier over mineral water practices

Date:
24 January 2024
Relevant legislation/regulation:
French regulation
Jurisdiction:
France
Status:
Ongoing
Regulator/enforcement authority:
French magistrate and French Senate committee
ESG Category:
Governance
Defendant(s)/subjects(s):
Perrier

Key Facts:

A 2024 investigation by Le Monde and Radio France stated that Perrier (owned by Nestlé), and a third of French mineral water sold in France, had been using prohibited purification techniques to treat “natural mineral water” due to concerns about water contamination. EU and French law requires mineral water to be unaltered from its source, with only minimal filtration allowed.

In 2024, Nestlé Waters admitted using banned filters and ultraviolet treatment on mineral waters, which must be processed naturally by law. To avoid legal action, Nestlé paid a €2.2 million fine. At the time Nestlé alleged that the government approved the replacement filters and that its water was “pure”.

A French Senate Committee reported in May 2025 that the French authorities had known about Nestle’s non-compliant treatment, had demonstrated minimal and/or delayed response to this, and that there had been strong lobbying by Nestle and over deference by the authorities to its demands. The report made a series of recommendations to restore consumer trust and reinforce compliance.

Following consumer complaints, a French magistrate also launched an investigation into Nestlé and rival bottler, Sources Alma, over suspicions of illegal processing of mineral water.

Nestlé has since claimed it has complied with the law by removing certain filtration devices at its southern French site but has yet to substantiate a claim that its water remains “pure”.

Sources: 

BBC article, Le Monde articles (8 May 2025 and 4 July 2025), Senate Committee report

Related Insights

The CMA’s latest guidance: making green claims across the supply chain

AI, advertising, and green claims: how the ASA is stepping up its game

ESG Enforcement Tracker featured in The Lawyer’s Spotlight

The hidden price tag: human rights and money laundering risks in supply chains

International Court of Justice confirms that States have a legal duty to protect and prevent harm to the climate

French lawmakers focus on ultra-fast fashion