The Disputes Brief

Weekly insights on the latest commercial judgments

When you know, you know: a Commercial Court judge’s instinct for whether there is a risk of dissipation should be trusted

 Court

Court of Appeal

 Issue

Test for the grant of a freezing order

 Outcome

The Court of Appeal dismissed the Claimant’s challenge to the first instance judge’s refusal to grant a freezing order 

 Key takeaway

It’s important not to delay in bringing an application for a freezing order 

 
 

In Lakatamia Shipping Company Ltd v Morimoto [2019] EWCA Civ 2203, Haddon-Cave LJ, quoting Longmore LJ, emphasised the respect appellate courts should give an experienced Commercial Court Judge’s assessment of whether a case is well arguable, unless the judge is plainly wrong. In Alliance Petrochemical Investment (Singapore) PTE Ltd v Mazzagatti & Anor [2026] EWCA Civ 1403, Butcher LJ held that the same approach applies to an assessment of whether there is a real risk of dissipation.

 

What’s the case about?

The Claimant in Alliance, a Singaporean company, alleges that the Defendants misappropriated almost €144m from it and its subsidiary. The Defendants vehemently deny all of the allegations against them.

 

What was the appeal about?

The appeal and cross-appeal covered four decisions arising from an interim hearing, including the Judge’s refusal to grant a worldwide freezing order against the Defendants, which is the focus of this piece.

 

Why did the Judge refuse to grant the freezing order?

For the court to grant a freezing order, the applicant must show that: (1) there is a serious issue to be tried; (2) there is a real risk, judged objectively, that a future judgment would not be met because of an unjustified dissipation of assets; and (3) that it would in all of the circumstances be just and convenient to grant the freezing order.

The Claimant commenced proceedings against one of the Defendants in Singapore in July 2023. The Claimant then commenced proceedings in England in August 2024. The Judge noted that the Claimant’s case had not materially changed over the years and the principal allegations of fraud and forgery against the Defendants had been the same all along. The Judge considered three more recent matters relied upon by the Claimant in support of its application, but did not consider these established a risk of dissipation. Acknowledging that delay in applying for a freezing order is not, by itself, dispositive, the Judge confirmed that it could be a powerful consideration when it came to assessing the risk of dissipation and, in this instance, it was fatal.

 

What was the basis of challenge?

The Claimant alleged that the Judge had failed to take into account the impact of its good arguable case of dishonesty, and all the evidence of the Defendants’ propensity to dissipate assets as part of a cumulative assessment of whether there was a risk of dissipation.

 

What did the Court of Appeal find?

Butcher LJ emphasised that the court had to consider all the evidence cumulatively. Read fairly, however, he was not persuaded that the Judge had adopted an incorrect approach. In addition to reiterating the principles that the Judge had applied, Butcher LJ added that Commercial Court Judges heard applications for freezing orders all the time and they developed an instinct for whether there is a real risk of dissipation. Appellate courts should be wary of interfering with the finding of an experienced Commercial Court judge that there was no real risk of dissipation.

Even if he was wrong about the Judge’s approach, Butcher LJ concluded that there was no solid evidence of a real risk of dissipation. His conclusion was based on the following:

  1. Dishonesty does not automatically establish a real risk of dissipation: Whilst a good arguable case of dishonesty may support an inference of dissipation, the case advanced by the Claimants was fully defended, supported by witness evidence and met by serious counter-allegations. The Defendants’ defences had not been struck out or summary judgment granted against them. In the circumstances, the court could not treat the Claimant as having established any more than there was a serious issue to be tried on the disputed matters.
  2. Early inferences not possible: At this stage of the proceedings, the Court was not in a position to find that foreign proceedings initiated by the Defendants were abusive, let alone that these gave rise to the inference that the Defendants would go to similar lengths to conceal and/or dissipate assets.
  3. Delay without evidence of dissipation matters: The basic nature of the allegations against the Defendants had been known to them for years. Despite this, the Claimant had not been able to produce any evidence that the Defendants had dissipated assets.
  4. Failure to provide voluntary disclosure of assets not fatal: The Defendants’ failure voluntarily to provide disclosure of their assets did not change Butcher LJ’s assessment, particularly in circumstances where the Defendants had a reason for failing to provide this information.
  5. Defendants’ positions not the same: Even if Butcher LJ had found there was a real risk of dissipation against one Defendant, he was not convinced this would be true of the other.
  6. Not just and convenient: Although it was not necessary to consider this part of the test for a freezing order, Butcher LJ agreed with the Judge about the potential effects of such an order on one of the Defendant’s businesses and the likelihood that the cross-undertaking in damages would cover the resulting loss. Butcher LJ therefore had reservations about whether the grant of a freezing order was just and convenient.

Butcher LJ dismissed the appeal in relation to the freezing order and the other Lord Justices agreed.

 

What is the takeaway?

Applicants should act promptly, but delay is not an automatic bar to a freezing order. Its significance depends on the evidence as a whole, including whether assets have been dissipated while the defendant knew of the claim. Serious allegations of dishonesty do not dispense with the need for solid evidence of a real risk of dissipation. Finally, the views of experienced judges should be respected where these concern issues such as whether there is a serious issue to be tried and whether there is a real risk of dissipation.

 

Frequently Asked Questions

What evidence do courts consider when assessing the risk of asset dissipation?

The court will look for evidence that a defendant is likely to move, conceal or dispose of assets in a way that could frustrate the enforcement of a future judgment. Relevant factors may include past asset transfers, the use of opaque corporate structures, inconsistent explanations about asset ownership, or conduct suggesting an intention to put assets beyond reach.

Can you obtain a freezing order which includes assets held abroad?

Yes. Freezing orders can restrain a defendant from dealing with assets located both within and outside England and Wales. However, the applicant must still satisfy the court that there is a real risk of dissipation and that granting the order is just and convenient.

Does a freezing order prevent a defendant from carrying on business?

Not usually, but it can have a significant effect on that business. Freezing orders are designed to preserve assets rather than prevent legitimate business activity. They commonly include exceptions allowing defendants to meet ordinary living expenses, pay legal costs and continue trading in the ordinary course of business, subject to the terms of the order.

 

Disclaimer: This article is provided for general information only and is accurate as of 8 November 2026. It may not be updated to reflect subsequent legal or other developments. It does not constitute legal advice and should not be relied on as such. Specific legal advice should be obtained in relation to particular circumstances.

Sign up to The Disputes Brief

*Required fields